[If she ate one of the eyeballs, she might chance upon a memory from the shirtless pirate thinking of feasts (?) and struggles. Which had to clash greatly with the sheer range of full emotions she could probably sense from him. It was a happy memory, clearly, he's laughing and smiling, but there's a lot of deep regret and sorrow, angst, anger, hatred, all fighting and clashing hard against the peace, love, and joy of being alive and remembering someone he clearly enjoyed just being around. None of which matched his face either! His grin wasn't carefree, and didn't seem to be deep in introspection, just determined and maybe even grim!]
feeding